My First Cream Pie 23

7.0 (1 votes)• 2023• 171m•Released

Storyline & Full Plot Breakdown

10x Extended

Minimized by default • Click to expand full plot & stills

Watch Full Movies At The Bottom ↓

Gwen is dangerously close to the deadline and she still needs to sell so many cookies. Luckily, she knocks on the door of a man who's willing to buy all her sweets if she's willing to share all her treats! Kenna and her girlfriends have made a pact to get pregnant at the same time. She lures her newly divorced next door neighbor over to get him to fill her wet pussy with his warm seed! Lily finds out she's pregnant, and goes to her dad's friend for some advice. He tells her how inappropriate it is for them to have this discussion, but when he caught Lily naked in his bed, he changes his mind! Natalia wants to get an invitation to a fraternity party so she offers to tutor the head of the frat. He declines, but when Natalia offers something every young man wants, he eagerly accepts.

Click to expand full storyline with movie images →1 Movie Images

Production Details

Languages: English

Starring Cast: Gwen Vicious, Kenna James, Lily Larimar, Natalia Nix, Bobby Beefcakes, Damon Dice

Cast

Gwen Vicious

Kenna James

Lily Larimar

Natalia Nix

Bobby Beefcakes

Damon Dice

Rion King

Audience Reviews & Breakdown

Read and share community scores for My First Cream Pie 23

2 Reviews

Recommended Reviews

Similar titles recommended for fans of My First Cream Pie 23

Milou’s strijd gaat door

Movie - 2025, 2h 15m

7.5 / 10

Documentary

When the cheerful, crazy, fun, and sweet Milou is confronted with multiple traumatic experiences in her early teens, she develops severe flashbacks and serious psychological problems. Everything is tried, but no one can silence the monster in her head. Milou is seventeen when she dies in her mother's arms. Weary, completely exhausted, she is finally allowed to go. Milou is the first minor in the Netherlands to die by euthanasia due to hopeless psychological suffering.

View Details

Block Pass

Movie - 2025, 2h 15m

6.6 / 10

Drama

Friendship and rebellion - but how will a secret play out in the masculine world of motocross? Willy and Jojo are best friends. They share a passion for motocross - whereas Willy uses it to honour his deceased father, it is only by excelling in the sport that Jojo’s father will notice him. Also the masculine world or racing is perfectly suited to suppress their own insecurities. Yet when Willy one fateful night discovers the hidden love life of Jojo, he will be forced to take sides in the wave of homophobia that follows.

View Details

My Summer with the Shark

Movie - 2023, 2h 15m

6.3 / 10

AdventureDrama

School's out and 13-year-old Walter has lost his father. In his seemingly aimless wanderings around the Roman coast, a fascinating and mysterious place catches his eye: an abandoned villa with a huge, murky swimming pool. But the villa is not unguarded...

View Details

Chemical Hearts

Movie - 2020, 2h 15m

7.3 / 10

DramaRomance

When a hopelessly romantic high school senior falls for a mysterious new classmate, it sets them both on an unexpected journey that teaches them about love, loss, and most importantly themselves.

View Details

Spontaneous

Movie - 2020, 2h 15m

6.8 / 10

ComedyHorror

When students in their high school begin inexplicably exploding (literally), seniors Mara and Dylan struggle to survive in a world where each moment may be their last.

View Details

Critters Attack!

Movie - 2020, 2h 15m

6.0 / 10

ComedyHorrorSci-Fi

Mysterious alien Critters have crash-landed in a small college town, devouring every living thing they encounter. Drea and the kids she's babysitting must try desperately to save themselves from the ravenous, rolling beasts. Will Drea discover her inner badass, and will it be enough to stop the Critter onslaught?

View Details